India’s current rate of spawning unicorns, or startups with at least a billion dollars in valuation, is almost three per month. But all that action is in private markets; practically nothing of the digital economy trades publicly. Which explains the nervous excitement over this week’s initial public offering by one of the country’s two dominant online food-delivery services.
As China cracks down on data-heavy businesses from finance to ride-hailing, Zomato Ltd., backed by Jack Ma’s Ant Group Co., is beefing up its IPO in the Indian market to Rs 9,375 crore ($1.3 billion) because of high demand.
At the top of the indicated price range, the app will have a market value of almost $8 billion, or 45% more than Jubilant Foodworks Ltd., which owns the South Asia franchise of Domino’s Pizza Inc. While Jubilant packs roughly a quarter of its revenue into earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortization, Zomato’s operations regularly bleed cash.
Naysayers may worry about paying so much for an unprofitable business. To the optimists, though, the losses at Zomato are reminiscent of Meituan’s decade-long journey to dominance. China’s third-largest publicly traded tech firm had started out as a Groupon clone, offering deals and discounts. It later added layers of Uber Eats-type online food delivery and Yelp-style restaurant reviews to become an all-purpose platform for services: a super-app. Zomato, which acquired Uber Eats’ India business before the pandemic – giving the U.S. ride-hailing firm a near-10% stake in return – is obviously looking to borrow from Meituan’s playbook.
But is it too late for that? Enterprises like Ant, Alibaba Group Holding Ltd. and Didi Global Inc., built around large-scale processing of consumer data, are suddenly under a regulatory cloud in Beijing. Meituan is also facing a monopoly probe. What’s the risk that New Delhi, too, will go the same way, upsetting calculations that India’s smartphone revolution would offer investors a refuge from the U.S.-China tech cold war?
Worrying signs are already evident. From Amazon.com Inc. to Facebook Inc.’s WhatsApp and Twitter Inc., Western tech firms are finding it hard to keep the market of 1.4 billion consumers open and attractive. New Delhi has weaponized its information technology and consumer protection legislation to target them. A law on personal data protection, and another on use of non-personal information, may be up next. That could be important for Zomato.
Compliance costs for handling online data are bound to rise. Even offline business practices could come under greater scrutiny. A restaurant association has asked India’s competition regulator to probe Zomato and rival Swiggy for allegedly charging exorbitant commissions and coaxing dining venues to offer discounts to maintain listings on their apps. Earlier this year, a restaurateur took to Twitter to complain about Zomato’s policy to punish food joints for cancellation of orders. Amid high unemployment, it’s possible that the government will want to push the cost of gig-economy workers’ social security to platforms that don’t directly employ them. (Zomato had nearly 170,000 delivery partners in March.)
The final shape of the country’s emerging digital economy is still unclear. Odds are that two or three large super-app contenders will emerge. One may be powered by Mukesh Ambani, India’s richest man, in partnership with Facebook and Alphabet Inc.’s Google. The other hopeful may be the Tata Group, a conglomerate that sells everything from Tetley tea to Jaguar Land Rover cars. For Zomato to place itself in the third place, it has to find partners to expand beyond food and health supplements into other services, such as payments and finance. Indonesia’s GoTo, the recently announced combination of e-commerce website PT Tokopedia with ride-hailing and delivery firm Gojek, offers a convincing model.
The timing for the share sale is opportunistic. After an initial wobble, Zomato proved its utility during the pandemic, when diners were stuck at home. At the same time, extraordinary liquidity support from the central bank has the equity market awash in cash. Info Edge India Ltd., the largest investor, will get a handsome partial exit as a reward for writing the fledgling firm a $1 million check in 2010.
What matters now is a path to profitability. At $137 million, the operational cash burn last financial year was less than half the annual rate just before Covid-19, and more than covered by private investors. From here on, though, the heavy lifting will have to be done by public shareholders. They would like to see Zomato pull off smart acquisitions that bring in both scale and cash flows. Dominance of consumer data alone won’t build a sustainable moat, as China’s harsh regulatory action has amply shown.
To its credit, Zomato’s pricey meal has arrived hot, beating other Indian unicorns. For sheer fear of missing out, investors have to dig in. For the less intrepid, there’s always Domino’s pizza.
(Andy Mukherjee is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist covering industrial companies and financial services. He previously was a columnist for Reuters Breakingviews. He has also worked for the Straits Times, ET NOW and Bloomberg News.)
Disclaimer: The opinions expressed within this article are the personal opinions of the author. The facts and opinions appearing in the article do not reflect the views of NDTV and NDTV does not assume any responsibility or liability for the same.
(Except for the headline, this story has not been edited by NDTV staff and is published from a syndicated feed.)